Cumming Turner & Watt has faced 12 tribunal cases since 2021, with 9 adverse outcomes (75% upheld or breach). Most recent: August 2026.

Tribunal Rating RED How is this calculated?

PFEO-weighted rate 98.0 per 10,000 (above 30).

12 Cases
75% Upheld (median: 50%)
98.0 Adjusted rate/10k (median: 6.8)
8 PFEOs
£16,218 Compensation

The adjusted rate weights PFEO-breached cases ×3.0 and complied cases ×1.5; the unweighted adverse rate is 40.1 per 10,000 properties. Benchmarks are sector medians across factors with at least one case since 2021.

Cases Over Time

2022
1
2023
1
2024
5
2025
3
2026
2

Outcomes

6 PFEO Breached 50.0%
1 PFEO Proposed 8.0%
2 PFEO Complied 17.0%
3 Rejected 25.0%

Complaint Types

Based on 7 analysed cases.

Communication
5
Maintenance
5
Other
3
Financial
3
Complaints Handling
3
Disclosure
1
Insurance
1

Enforcement & Compensation

Enforcement Orders (PFEOs)

8 of 12 cases (66%)

Compensation Awarded

£16,218 total

Largest: £5,000 (FTS/HPC/PF/24/0904)

Notable Cases

FTS/HPC/PF/24/0904
PFEO Proposed
2025-12-03 · £5,000 compensation

The Tribunal found Cumming, Turner and Watt had breached the Code of Conduct by failing to respond to complaints and manage repairs. A Proposed Property Factor Enforcement Order was issued, including an apology and compensation of £5,000.

"The Tribunal therefore considers that the Respondent’s breaches have had extremely serious consequences and ought to be treated at the highest end of the scale of severity which the Tribunal uses to assess such matters."
FTS/HPC/PF/21/1377
PFEO Complied ⚠ PFEO Issued
2022-02-03 · £2,653 compensation

PFEO made 18 November 2021; a failure-to-comply decision followed on 19 January 2022 with a proposed payment order of £2,653.20 (£1,453.20 refund + £1,000 + £200); the factor then complied and a Certificate of Compliance was issued after payment on 3 February 2022.

Other
"The Tribunal determines that the Factor has failed to comply with the Property Factor Enforcement Order imposed by it in respect of the Property and dated 18 November 2021(“PFEO”)."
FTS/HPC/PF/23/1578
PFEO Breached ⚠ PFEO Issued
2024-03-28 · £2,000 compensation

The tribunal found that the factor had failed to comply with the previously issued Property Factor Enforcement Order.

Communication Financial Maintenance Insurance Complaints Handling Other
"The Tribunal determined that the Property Factor: - Has failed to comply with the Property Factor Enforcement Order which was issued on 10th January 2024."

All Cases

Date Reference Outcome PFEO Comp.
2026-08-05 24/1647 PFEO Breached PFEO £1,000 Details
2026-05-14 23/2234 PFEO Complied PFEO £1,500 Details
2025-12-03 24/0904 PFEO Proposed — £5,000 Details
2025-03-17 23/4244 PFEO Breached PFEO £1,500 Details
2025-02-25 22/3836 PFEO Breached PFEO £1,000 Details
2024-11-06 24/283924/2839 Rejected — — Details
2024-08-15 23/1109 PFEO Breached PFEO £300 Details
2024-07-04 23/2601 Rejected — — Details
2024-05-28 23/1594 PFEO Breached PFEO £1,265 Details
2024-03-28 23/1578 PFEO Breached PFEO £2,000 Details
2023-05-22 23/1651 Rejected — — Details
2022-02-03 21/1377 PFEO Complied PFEO £2,653 Details

Data from Housing & Property Chamber. Cases decided since 2021..

Case Details

Click "Details" in the table above to jump to a case.

24/1647 2026-08-05
PFEO Breached PFEO Issued £1,000

Multiple breaches of the 2021 Code; a PFEO made on 19 November 2025 ordered £1,000, which was paid. On 5 August 2026 the tribunal determined the factor had failed to comply with the order — the non-monetary requirements (apology letters and staff training) were not evidenced and the factor did not respond.

Communication Maintenance Other
"The Factor shall pay the Applicants the sum of £1000.00 for the worry, distress and inconvenience suffered by them as a result of the Factor’s breach of the 2021 Code."
23/2234 2026-05-14
PFEO Complied PFEO Issued £1,500

Breaches under the 2012 and 2021 Codes affecting three owners; a PFEO made on 19 February 2026 ordered £500 to each applicant (£1,500 in total), and compliance was confirmed on 14 May 2026.

"Having made the above findings, the Tribunal proposes to make a Property Factor Enforcement Order in terms of Section 19 (2) of the Act."
24/0904 2025-12-03
PFEO Proposed £5,000

The Tribunal found Cumming, Turner and Watt had breached the Code of Conduct by failing to respond to complaints and manage repairs. A Proposed Property Factor Enforcement Order was issued, including an apology and compensation of £5,000.

"The Tribunal therefore considers that the Respondent’s breaches have had extremely serious consequences and ought to be treated at the highest end of the scale of severity which the Tribunal uses to assess such matters."
23/4244 2025-03-17
PFEO Breached PFEO Issued £1,500

A PFEO was made on 22 October 2024 (£1,500, paid, plus a float refund). On 17 March 2025 the Tribunal found the factor had failed to comply with points 1, 3 and 4 of the order.

Communication Financial Disclosure Complaints Handling
"The Property Factor has made errors and therefore, the Tribunal proposes to make a PFEO."
22/3836 2025-02-25
PFEO Breached PFEO Issued £1,000

The tribunal found that Cumming Turner & Watt failed to comply with the Property Factor Enforcement Order that was made on 9 January 2024.

Maintenance
"The tribunal determined that the property factors have failed to comply with the terms of the Property Factor Enforcement Order made on 9 January 2024"
24/283924/2839 2024-11-06
Rejected

The tribunal rejected the homeowner's application because the homeowner failed to provide required documentation as per the rules.

"The Legal Member therefore determines that the application cannot be accepted. The application is rejected on that basis."
23/1109 2024-08-15
PFEO Breached PFEO Issued £300

The Tribunal found the factor failed to communicate adequately with the homeowner, and issued a PFEO. The factor failed to comply with the PFEO.

Communication Maintenance
"The Tribunal now confirms that the Respondent has failed to comply with the terms of that Order."
23/2601 2024-07-04
Rejected

The tribunal rejected the application because the homeowner failed to provide requested information, including evidence of notifying the property factor of their concerns.

"The Legal Member therefore determines that the application cannot be accepted. The application is rejected on that basis."
23/1594 2024-05-28
PFEO Breached PFEO Issued £1,265

The tribunal found the factor had partially complied with the PFEO, but not fully. The Tribunal determined the factor failed to fully comply with the PFEO.

Communication Maintenance Financial Complaints Handling
"The Tribunal determined that the Property Factor has failed to comply with the Property Factor Enforcement Order (PFEO) dated 1 December 2023."
23/1578 2024-03-28
PFEO Breached PFEO Issued £2,000

The tribunal found that the factor had failed to comply with the previously issued Property Factor Enforcement Order.

Communication Financial Maintenance Insurance Complaints Handling Other
"The Tribunal determined that the Property Factor: - Has failed to comply with the Property Factor Enforcement Order which was issued on 10th January 2024."
23/1651 2023-05-22
Rejected

The tribunal rejected the application because the applicant did not provide required information, specifically evidence of notifying the factor of their concerns.

"The Legal Member therefore determines that the application cannot be accepted. The application is rejected on that basis."
21/1377 2022-02-03
PFEO Complied PFEO Issued £2,653

PFEO made 18 November 2021; a failure-to-comply decision followed on 19 January 2022 with a proposed payment order of £2,653.20 (£1,453.20 refund + £1,000 + £200); the factor then complied and a Certificate of Compliance was issued after payment on 3 February 2022.

Other
"The Tribunal determines that the Factor has failed to comply with the Property Factor Enforcement Order imposed by it in respect of the Property and dated 18 November 2021(“PFEO”)."

How We Calculate Ratings

Ratings are based on a factor's adjusted adverse case rate per 10,000 properties for cases decided since 2021. Cases involving Property Factor Enforcement Orders (PFEOs) are weighted more heavily.

Rating Bands

CLEAN No cases decided against the factor since 2021
GREEN PFEO-weighted adverse rate at or below 10 per 10,000 properties (or 2 or fewer adverse cases with no PFEO breach)
ORANGE Weighted rate above 10 and up to 30 per 10,000
RED PFEO-weighted adverse rate above 30 per 10,000 properties
LIMITED Fewer than 50 properties on record to rate reliably

Special Rules

  • Factors with only 2 or fewer adverse cases (no PFEO breaches) are capped at GREEN
  • Pending or proposed PFEOs count at ×1.0 until the outcome is decided — there is no minimum-band override

Read our full methodology →

Data Updates

  • Last updated: October 2026
  • Next update: Monthly

We update quarterly. For the latest decisions, search the HPC directly →

Looking for alternatives?

We'll shortlist vetted factors with better tribunal records covering your area — free, no obligation.

Find a Better Factor

← Back to Cumming Turner & Watt profile