Walker Sandford Property Management Limited has faced 6 tribunal cases since 2021, with 3 adverse outcomes (50% upheld or breach). Most recent: July 2026.

Tribunal Rating ORANGE How is this calculated?

PFEO-weighted rate 19.0 per 10,000 (10–30).

6 Cases
50% Upheld (median: 50%)
19.0 Adjusted rate/10k (median: 6.8)
2 PFEOs
£5,150 Compensation

The adjusted rate weights PFEO-breached cases ×3.0 and complied cases ×1.5; the unweighted adverse rate is 14.2 per 10,000 properties. Benchmarks are sector medians across factors with at least one case since 2021.

Cases Over Time

2021
1
2022
2
2023
1
2024
1
2026
1

Outcomes

1 PFEO Proposed 17.0%
2 PFEO Complied 33.0%
3 Dismissed 50.0%

Complaint Types

Based on 5 analysed cases.

Communication
4
Maintenance
3
Complaints Handling
3
Financial
3
Debt Recovery
1

Enforcement & Compensation

Enforcement Orders (PFEOs)

2 of 6 cases (33%)

Compensation Awarded

£5,150 total

Largest: £5,000 (FTS/HPC/PF/24/0587)

Notable Cases

FTS/HPC/PF/24/0587
PFEO Complied ⚠ PFEO Issued
2026-07-14 · £5,000 compensation

The respondent property factor was found to have breached both the 2012 and 2021 Codes of Conduct by failing to manage a persistent communal roof leak over several years, including extended periods of complete non-engagement with the homeowner. Official complaints were ignored, and the homeowner ultimately paid £5,160 plus VAT for internal repairs — costs the Tribunal found were likely to have been significantly increased by the respondent's failure to take adequate action on the common repairs. A PFEO requiring a written apology and £5,000 compensation was made on 11 June 2026 and subsequently complied with, leading to revocation on 14 July 2026.

Communication Maintenance Complaints Handling
"there were periods of substantial time, including on one occasion an entire calendar year when the Respondent literally did not communicate or engage with the Applicant about the issue"
FTS/HPC/PF/23/1193
PFEO Complied ⚠ PFEO Issued
2024-10-03

The tribunal found the property factor in breach of the 2012 Code by failing to carry out annual inspections. The tribunal proposed making a Property Factor Enforcement Order.

Communication Financial Maintenance Complaints Handling
"The First-tier Tribunal proposed to make a Property Factor Enforcement Order."

All Cases

Date Reference Outcome PFEO Comp.
2026-07-14 24/0587 PFEO Complied PFEO £5,000 Details
2024-10-03 23/1193 PFEO Complied PFEO — Details
2023-01-13 22/1049 PFEO Proposed — £150 Details
2022-03-17 21/2988 Dismissed — — Details
2022-02-04 21/2686 Dismissed — — Details
2021-08-12 21/0629 Dismissed — — Details

Data from Housing & Property Chamber. Cases decided since 2021..

Case Details

Click "Details" in the table above to jump to a case.

24/0587 2026-07-14
PFEO Complied PFEO Issued £5,000

The respondent property factor was found to have breached both the 2012 and 2021 Codes of Conduct by failing to manage a persistent communal roof leak over several years, including extended periods of complete non-engagement with the homeowner. Official complaints were ignored, and the homeowner ultimately paid £5,160 plus VAT for internal repairs — costs the Tribunal found were likely to have been significantly increased by the respondent's failure to take adequate action on the common repairs. A PFEO requiring a written apology and £5,000 compensation was made on 11 June 2026 and subsequently complied with, leading to revocation on 14 July 2026.

Communication Maintenance Complaints Handling
"there were periods of substantial time, including on one occasion an entire calendar year when the Respondent literally did not communicate or engage with the Applicant about the issue"
23/1193 2024-10-03
PFEO Complied PFEO Issued

The tribunal found the property factor in breach of the 2012 Code by failing to carry out annual inspections. The tribunal proposed making a Property Factor Enforcement Order.

Communication Financial Maintenance Complaints Handling
"The First-tier Tribunal proposed to make a Property Factor Enforcement Order."
22/1049 2023-01-13
PFEO Proposed £150

The Tribunal found the property factor in breach of the Code of Conduct and proposed a PFEO that includes a written apology and compensation of £150.

Communication Maintenance Complaints Handling
"The Tribunal proposes to make a Property Factor enforcement order ("PFEO")."
21/2988 2022-03-17
Dismissed

The homeowner alleged the Property Factor failed to take adequate action to recover unpaid factoring invoices. The Tribunal found in favor of the Property Factor, dismissing the application.

Communication Financial
"The Property Factor has not failed to comply with its duties under section 14(5) of the Property Factors (Scotland) Act 2011 Act in that it did not fail to comply with Section 4 of the Code of Conduct for Property Factors."
21/2686 2022-02-04
Dismissed

The homeowner alleged breaches of the Code of Practice regarding debt recovery charges. The tribunal found the charges were not unreasonable or excessive, and dismissed the application.

Financial Debt Recovery
"Accordingly, the Tribunal declined to uphold the sole remaining complaint based upon section 4.3 of the 2012 Code and dismissed the application."
21/0629 2021-08-12
Dismissed

The Tribunal dismissed the application because it found that Acony Bell Properties Limited was not acting as a property factor within the meaning of the 2011 Act, but as a property developer.

"The First-tier Tribunal for Scotland Housing and Property Chamber (“the Tribunal”), determined that the Respondents are not property factors within the meaning of Section 2(1) of the Property Factors (Scotland) Act 2011 and that, as the Tribunal did not, therefore, have jurisdiction to hear the application, the application must be dismissed"

How We Calculate Ratings

Ratings are based on a factor's adjusted adverse case rate per 10,000 properties for cases decided since 2021. Cases involving Property Factor Enforcement Orders (PFEOs) are weighted more heavily.

Rating Bands

CLEAN No cases decided against the factor since 2021
GREEN PFEO-weighted adverse rate at or below 10 per 10,000 properties (or 2 or fewer adverse cases with no PFEO breach)
ORANGE Weighted rate above 10 and up to 30 per 10,000
RED PFEO-weighted adverse rate above 30 per 10,000 properties
LIMITED Fewer than 50 properties on record to rate reliably

Special Rules

  • Factors with only 2 or fewer adverse cases (no PFEO breaches) are capped at GREEN
  • Pending or proposed PFEOs count at ×1.0 until the outcome is decided — there is no minimum-band override

Read our full methodology →

Data Updates

  • Last updated: October 2026
  • Next update: Monthly

We update quarterly. For the latest decisions, search the HPC directly →

Looking for alternatives?

We'll shortlist vetted factors with better tribunal records covering your area — free, no obligation.

Find a Better Factor

← Back to Walker Sandford Property Management Limited profile