Newton Property Management Ltd has faced 46 tribunal cases since 2021, with 26 adverse outcomes (57% upheld or breach). Most recent: September 2026.

Tribunal Rating GREEN How is this calculated?

PFEO-weighted rate 8.9 per 10,000 (at or below 10).

46 Cases
57% Upheld (median: 50%)
8.9 Adjusted rate/10k (median: 6.8)
17 PFEOs
£11,500 Compensation

The adjusted rate weights PFEO-breached cases ×3.0 and complied cases ×1.5; the unweighted adverse rate is 6.8 per 10,000 properties. Benchmarks are sector medians across factors with at least one case since 2021.

Cases Over Time

2021
3
2022
4
2023
6
2024
8
2025
10
2026
15

Outcomes

3 Breach - No Order 7.0%
7 PFEO Proposed 15.0%
16 PFEO Complied 35.0%
13 Dismissed 28.0%
6 Rejected 13.0%
1 Withdrawn 2.0%

Complaint Types

Based on 30 analysed cases.

Communication
26
Financial
14
Other
11
Complaints Handling
10
Maintenance
10
Consultation
6
Disclosure
3
Debt Recovery
3

Enforcement & Compensation

Enforcement Orders (PFEOs)

17 of 46 cases (36%)

Compensation Awarded

£11,500 total

Largest: £3,000 (FTS/HPC/PF/25/1236)

Notable Cases

FTS/HPC/PF/25/1236
PFEO Complied ⚠ PFEO Issued
2026-07-27 · £3,000 compensation

Twelve homeowners at a Lochwinnoch development applied against their property factor following a portfolio takeover, citing failures across transition, termination accounting, debt communication, and handover to the successor factor. The Tribunal found breaches of Code paragraphs 2.9, 3.5, 3.6, 4.1, 4.9 and 7.5 (paragraph 4.6 was not breached), and made a PFEO on 29 June 2026 requiring £250 per applicant (£3,000 in total). A Certificate of Compliance was issued on 27 July 2026 confirming the order had been satisfied.

Communication Financial Disclosure
"The Respondent's attitude to the Applicants and the customer service throughout was disappointing. They appear to have been treated as a commodity rather than customers/clients."
FTS/HPC/PF/24/4653
PFEO Pending ⚠ PFEO Issued
2026-06-24 · £1,500 compensation

The Tribunal found the respondent had breached sections 2.1, 2.4, 2.7, 6.1, 6.4, 6.6, 6.12 and 7.1 of the Code of Conduct for Property Factors 2021 in a decision dated 26 May 2026. A proposed PFEO was issued and, no representations having been received from the respondent, a final PFEO was made on 24 June 2026. The PFEO requires the respondent to pay £1,500 to the applicant and to provide a formal written apology within 28 days, with compliance not yet confirmed.

Communication Complaints Handling Financial
"the Respondent must pay to the Applicant the sum of £1500 from its own funds into the Applicant's bank account within 28 days of intimation of the final PFEO"
FTS/HPC/PF/24/5106
PFEO Complied ⚠ PFEO Issued
2025-11-14 · £1,000 compensation

The Tribunal found Newton Property Management in breach of the Code of Conduct. The Tribunal issued a Property Factor Enforcement Order requiring the factor to credit charges and pay compensation.

"We propose to make a property factor enforcement order (“PFEO”)."

All Cases

Date Reference Outcome PFEO Comp.
2026-09-17 24/4854 PFEO Pending PFEO £500 Details
2026-08-05 25/3945 Dismissed — — Details
2026-07-27 25/0299 PFEO Proposed — £600 Details
2026-07-27 25/1236 PFEO Complied PFEO £3,000 Details
2026-07-27 25/2804 PFEO Pending PFEO — Details
2026-07-18 25/0308 Rejected — — Details
2026-06-24 24/4653 PFEO Pending PFEO £1,500 Details
2026-06-21 FTS/HPC/LM/24/2967 PFEO Pending PFEO £250 Details
2026-06-01 25/0821 Dismissed — — Details
2026-04-17 25/2434 PFEO Proposed — £250 Details
2026-03-09 24/3874 PFEO Complied PFEO — Details
2026-03-05 25/3277 Dismissed — — Details
2026-02-18 25/1100 PFEO Complied PFEO £100 Details
2026-02-17 24/4314 PFEO Complied PFEO £350 Details
2026-01-15 25/2070 Dismissed — — Details
2025-12-08 25/1261 PFEO Proposed — £100 Details
2025-11-14 24/5106 PFEO Complied PFEO £1,000 Details
2025-11-12 23/4574 Breach - No Order — — Details
2025-08-29 24/2727 PFEO Complied PFEO £100 Details
2025-08-01 24/2146 Dismissed — — Details
2025-08-01 24/2145 Dismissed — — Details
2025-07-28 24/5675 Dismissed — — Details
2025-07-04 24/3014 PFEO Complied PFEO £150 Details
2025-03-18 FTS/HPC/LM/23/4475 PFEO Complied PFEO — Details
2025-02-06 24/5160 Withdrawn — — Details
2024-12-19 24/1954 Breach - No Order — — Details
2024-12-16 24/0921 Breach - No Order — — Details
2024-10-23 24/1556 PFEO Complied PFEO — Details
2024-06-25 23/2978 PFEO Complied PFEO £250 Details
2024-06-21 24/0298 Dismissed — — Details
2024-01-29 23/1912 PFEO Complied PFEO £500 Details
2024-01-15 23/0337 Dismissed — — Details
2024-01-08 23/0006+0367 Dismissed — — Details
2023-11-06 22/4041 Dismissed — — Details
2023-11-06 23/1246 Dismissed — — Details
2023-05-25 22/4172 Rejected — — Details
2023-05-17 22/1586 Rejected — — Details
2023-05-03 22/4180 Rejected — — Details
2023-03-08 21/3219 PFEO Complied PFEO £750 Details
2022-11-23 22/1769 Dismissed — — Details
2022-05-31 22/1654/1655 PFEO Complied PFEO £500 Details
2022-02-17 FTS/HPC/LM/21/2188 PFEO Complied — £862 Details
2022-02-17 21/1283 PFEO Complied — £637 Details
2021-09-06 21/1412 PFEO Complied — £100 Details
2021-08-30 21/1436 Rejected — — Details
2021-08-05 21/0429 Rejected — — Details

Data from Housing & Property Chamber. Cases decided since 2021..

Case Details

Click "Details" in the table above to jump to a case.

24/4854 2026-09-17
PFEO Pending PFEO Issued £500

The Tribunal found Newton Property Management Ltd in breach of the Code of Conduct (OSP3 and sections 3.1, 3.2 and 7.2) and of its property factor duties, chiefly over systematic invoicing errors on a retirement development (around £15,917 credited back to homeowners), failure to hold a £103,000 contingency fund in an interest-bearing account as the Deed of Conditions required, and failure to confirm its final complaints decision in writing. A Property Factor Enforcement Order was made on 17 September 2026 requiring £500 compensation and a plan to calculate lost interest on the fund, with 30 days to comply; compliance has not yet been certified.

Financial Disclosure Complaints Handling
"The Tribunal hereby makes the following Property Factor Enforcement Order (“PFEO”)."
25/3945 2026-08-05
Dismissed

A homeowner complained that the respondent had breached Clause 7.6 of the 2021 Code by failing to provide adequate proof of its valid appointment as property factor, following its acquisition of the previous factor's business. The Tribunal held a CMD and decided the matter on papers and oral evidence, finding that the respondent had explained the basis of its appointment by emails in August 2025 and that no breach of Clause 7.6 was established. The application was dismissed.

"Following consideration of papers and oral discussions the Tribunal decided that there had been no breach of Section 7.6 of the 2021 Code."
25/0299 2026-07-27
PFEO Proposed £600

The homeowner complained that the property factor repeatedly made errors in invoicing, including inconsistent apportionment of electricity charges, overpayment to the electricity supplier with late fees passed on without disclosure, and failure to respond to formal complaints under its own procedure. The Tribunal found breaches of OSP 2, 3, 4, 6, 11 and Code sections 2.7, 3.1, 3.2, 7.1 and 7.2, but not OSP 1. A Proposed PFEO was issued requiring procedural remediation and payment of £600 compensation to the homeowner.

Communication Financial Complaints Handling Disclosure
"There is an abject failure on the part of the Property Factor to accept that it breached any part of the Code."
25/1236 2026-07-27
PFEO Complied PFEO Issued £3,000

Twelve homeowners at a Lochwinnoch development applied against their property factor following a portfolio takeover, citing failures across transition, termination accounting, debt communication, and handover to the successor factor. The Tribunal found breaches of Code paragraphs 2.9, 3.5, 3.6, 4.1, 4.9 and 7.5 (paragraph 4.6 was not breached), and made a PFEO on 29 June 2026 requiring £250 per applicant (£3,000 in total). A Certificate of Compliance was issued on 27 July 2026 confirming the order had been satisfied.

Communication Financial Disclosure
"The Respondent's attitude to the Applicants and the customer service throughout was disappointing. They appear to have been treated as a commodity rather than customers/clients."
25/2804 2026-07-27
PFEO Pending PFEO Issued

The tribunal found the respondent had breached the Code of Conduct by failing to communicate effectively with the homeowner and by not responding timeously to enquiries, in the context of long-running and serious disrepair at a tenement in Aberdeen requiring major common works. A proposed PFEO was issued on 2 June 2026 and, after representations (including a formal undertaking from the respondent), the final PFEO was made on 27 July 2026 requiring the respondent to communicate effectively on works progress and grant applications. No compensation was ordered as the tribunal found the communication failures had not delayed the works programme.

Communication
"The Respondent had breached the Code but its failure to comply had not impacted on the timescale for works to be progressed."
25/0308 2026-07-18
Rejected

The homeowner applied under Section 17 of the Property Factors (Scotland) Act 2011 regarding property at 6 Mill Wynd, Waterside, Kilmarnock. Despite two directed requests and a Case Management Discussion in March 2026, the applicant failed to identify the specific Code or Overarching Standards of Practice sections alleged to have been breached, and failed to attend or provide reasons for absence at the CMD on 16 July 2026. The Tribunal rejected both applications under Rule 8.1(c) on the grounds that there was good reason to believe it would not be appropriate to accept them.

"the Tribunal believes that there is good reason to reject the application under Rule 8(1)(c)"
24/4653 2026-06-24
PFEO Pending PFEO Issued £1,500

The Tribunal found the respondent had breached sections 2.1, 2.4, 2.7, 6.1, 6.4, 6.6, 6.12 and 7.1 of the Code of Conduct for Property Factors 2021 in a decision dated 26 May 2026. A proposed PFEO was issued and, no representations having been received from the respondent, a final PFEO was made on 24 June 2026. The PFEO requires the respondent to pay £1,500 to the applicant and to provide a formal written apology within 28 days, with compliance not yet confirmed.

Communication Complaints Handling Financial
"the Respondent must pay to the Applicant the sum of £1500 from its own funds into the Applicant's bank account within 28 days of intimation of the final PFEO"
FTS/HPC/LM/24/2967 2026-06-21
PFEO Pending PFEO Issued £250

A homeowner at a 222-property development applied under the Property Factors (Scotland) Act 2011 alleging the respondent failed to carry out its property factor duties in relation to development debt management and refusal to accept termination of its contract. The Tribunal found a breach on two grounds: failing to keep homeowners informed of the level and details of the development debt, and failing to take reasonable steps to pursue recovery including court action. A PFEO was made on 21 June 2026 ordering full debt disclosure, consultation on a debt recovery policy, clarification of the termination threshold, and payment of £250 compensation.

Communication Financial
"The Tribunal is therefore satisfied that the Respondent has failed to carry out its property factor duties to a reasonable standard in the management of the development debt. It has not kept the Applicant informed and has not taken appropriate and reasonable steps to secure payment."
25/0821 2026-06-01
Dismissed

A homeowner alleged breaches of the Code of Conduct (the Tribunal applied the 2012 and 2021 Codes) relating to pest control and painting works at a coastal property in Prestwick. The Tribunal considered submissions from both parties at a case management discussion and found on a balance of probabilities that the factor had engaged with contractors, followed its complaints procedure, and adhered to its Written Statement of Services. The application was unanimously dismissed.

"the Tribunal decided that on a balance of Probabilities the Applicant had not made out his case"
25/2434 2026-04-17
PFEO Proposed £250

The respondent, acting as factor for a mixed development of flats and mews houses, arranged a single block buildings insurance policy covering both tenement and mews common parts and required all owners including mews owners to contribute. The tribunal found this breached the Code of Conduct because mews owners have no liability for, or insurable interest in, the tenement or its common parts, and the respondent therefore misrepresented the applicant's insurance obligations. A proposed PFEO was issued requiring corrective communications to all owners, refund of insurance payments, removal of related charges, and payment of £250 compensation.

Insurance
"the factor could decide to take out or maintain a common block insurance policy to cover the tenement but cannot require the owners of the mews to contribute to a policy which includes a risk (to the Tenement Common Parts) for which they have no interest in or liability for."
24/3874 2026-03-09
PFEO Complied PFEO Issued

Breaches found 16 December 2025; a PFEO (revise the Written Statement of Services) was made on 9 March 2026 and certified complied (certificate published June 2026).

"The Tribunal find that there has been a breach of the Code in this regard.It can only be concluded for the reasons we have detailed in our decision regarding OSP2, that the Respondent has provided deliberately misleading information."
25/3277 2026-03-05
Dismissed

The homeowner alleged breaches of the Property Factors Code of Conduct. The Tribunal reviewed the case and found the property factor had not breached the Code, dismissing the application.

"The First-tier Tribunal for Scotland Housing and Property Chamber determined that the property factors have not failed to comply with Sections 1.5.B or 1.5.C of the Property Factors Code of Conduct effective from 16 August 2021 and have not failed to carry out the property factor’s duties."
25/1100 2026-02-18
PFEO Complied PFEO Issued £100

The tribunal found the factor in breach of the code for delaying repairs. The tribunal issued a Property Factor Enforcement Order for the factor to pay the homeowners £100.

"The Factor must pay the Homeowners £100 for the inconvenience they have suffered from their own funds and at no cost to the owners. The sums to be paid within 28 days of the communication to the Factor of the Property Factor Enforcement Order."
24/4314 2026-02-17
PFEO Complied PFEO Issued £350

Breach of OSP2; a PFEO made on 12 February 2026 ordered £350, and compliance was certified after payment on 17 February 2026.

"The Tribunal determine that the Factor has not been fair with the Homeowner in relation to the acceptance of liability for maintenance of the surface water drainage system on 18th January 2023 when they knew that the system was faulty and there had been an incident of flooding three days before."
25/2070 2026-01-15
Dismissed

The homeowner's application was dismissed by the tribunal because the applicant did not attend the hearing.

"The Tribunal members...applied Rule 27 2b of the Procedure Rules and dismissed the Application."
25/1261 2025-12-08
PFEO Proposed £100

The tribunal found that Newton Property Management failed to comply with their duties and breached the Code of Conduct, and proposes to issue a Property Factor Enforcement Order.

"The tribunal therefore proposes to make a property factor enforcement order under section 19 of the Property Factors (Scotland) Act 2011."
24/5106 2025-11-14
PFEO Complied PFEO Issued £1,000

The Tribunal found Newton Property Management in breach of the Code of Conduct. The Tribunal issued a Property Factor Enforcement Order requiring the factor to credit charges and pay compensation.

"We propose to make a property factor enforcement order (“PFEO”)."
23/4574 2025-11-12
Breach - No Order

The tribunal found the factor had breached the code by not responding to a complaint in the required timeframe, but declined to issue a PFEO.

Communication Financial Other
"The Tribunal therefore does not propose to make a Property Factor Enforcement Order."
24/2727 2025-08-29
PFEO Complied PFEO Issued £100

The Tribunal found Newton Property Management Limited in breach of the Code of Conduct and issued a Property Factor Enforcement Order. The factor subsequently complied with the order.

Other
"The Tribunal determined that the Factor had failed to comply with OSP 11 and section 3.1 of the 2021 Code of Conduct..."
24/2146 2025-08-01
Dismissed

The tribunal found that the property factor had not failed to comply with the Code of Conduct and dismissed the homeowner's application.

Communication Debt Recovery
"Accordingly, the Tribunal dismissed the Application."
24/2145 2025-08-01
Dismissed

The Tribunal dismissed the homeowner's application because he had not complied with Section 17(3) of the PF Act, specifically regarding prior written notification of the breach to the property factor.

Communication Debt Recovery Other
"The First-tier Tribunal for Scotland (Housing and Property Chamber) (“the Tribunal”) having determined that the Homeowne had not complied with Section 17(3) of the PF Act dismissed the Application."
24/5675 2025-07-28
Dismissed

The homeowner alleged the property factor breached the Code of Conduct. The tribunal found no breaches and dismissed the application.

Financial Communication Other
"The First-tier Tribunal for Scotland Housing and Property Chamber determined that the property factors have not failed to comply with OSP2, OSP6 or Section 3.2 of the Property Factors Code of Conduct effective from 16 August 2021 and have not failed to comply with the property factor’s duties."
24/3014 2025-07-04
PFEO Complied PFEO Issued £150

The tribunal found the factor breached its duties regarding how it sought consent for works and issued a PFEO for £150 compensation. The factor later complied with the order.

Communication Maintenance Consultation
"The Property Factor is required, within 30 days of the making of this Property Factor Enforcement Order, to make payment of the sum of £150.00 from their own funds to compensate the Homeowner for the frustration and inconvenience caused as a result of the Property Factor’s failure to carry out its property factor duties.’"
FTS/HPC/LM/23/4475 2025-03-18
PFEO Complied PFEO Issued

The tribunal found that Newton Property Management Limited breached the Code of Conduct, section 3.2, for lack of clarity and transparency in processes for managing invoicing errors. A PFEO was proposed, then issued, and Newton complied with the PFEO.

Communication Financial Other
"The First-tier Tribunal (Housing and Property Chamber) (“the tribunal”) decided in terms of Section 23(1) of the 2011 Act that that the Property Factor has complied with the terms of the Property Factor Enforcement Order (“PFEO”) dated 23 June 2025."
24/5160 2025-02-06
Withdrawn

The applicant withdrew part of their complaint and the application was rejected because the applicant failed to provide necessary information.

"The Applicant wrote to the Tribunal and intimated that he was “withdrawing the door complaint.”"
24/1954 2024-12-19
Breach - No Order

The tribunal found Newton Property Management failed to comply with OSP 11 by not responding to a complaint within the required timeframe. However, the Tribunal decided not to issue a Property Factor Enforcement Order (PFEO).

Communication Other
"The Tribunal does not propose to make a PFEO in the circumstances."
24/0921 2024-12-16
Breach - No Order

The tribunal found a breach of the Property Factor's duties related to the complaints resolution procedure but decided against issuing a Property Factor Enforcement Order.

Communication Maintenance Financial Other Complaints Handling
"The Tribunal determined not to make a Property Factor Enforcement Order (PFEO)"
24/1556 2024-10-23
PFEO Complied PFEO Issued

The tribunal found the factor breached the code by not providing sufficient notice of fee increases. A PFEO was issued, requiring the factor to refund the fee increase, and the factor complied.

Communication Financial Complaints Handling
"The Tribunal makes the following PFEO: No later than 4 weeks from 28 February 2025 the Property Factor must: 1. Refund the Applicant the increase in the management fees from 1 March 2024 to 30 November 2024."
23/2978 2024-06-25
PFEO Complied PFEO Issued £250

The tribunal found the factor breached the Code of Conduct by providing misleading information in a Trustpilot review and failing to deal with the lock issues in a timely way. The tribunal issued a PFEO requiring the factor to remove or correct the review, provide training, and pay compensation.

Communication Maintenance Complaints Handling
"The Tribunal hereby makes the following PFEO: The Property Factor is required to carry out the following within 21 days of issue of the PFEO: "
24/0298 2024-06-21
Dismissed

The tribunal found that the property factor had not breached the code of conduct, therefore the application was dismissed.

Communication Maintenance
"Has not failed to comply with Section 14 duty in terms of the Act in respect of compliance with the Property Factor Code of Conduct 2021“,"
23/1912 2024-01-29
PFEO Complied PFEO Issued £500

The tribunal found the factor had breached the Code of Conduct by failing to retain copies of correspondence. A PFEO was issued, requiring payment of compensation and the provision of a document; the factor complied with the order.

Communication
"The tribunal therefore determines to make a property factor enforcement order (PFEO) in terms of section 19 of the 2011 Act in the terms previously proposed in its original decision dated 8 January 2024."
23/0337 2024-01-15
Dismissed

The homeowner alleged breaches of the Code of Conduct. The tribunal found no breaches and dismissed the application, making no further orders.

Other Maintenance Consultation
"The tribunal has therefore decided to make no further order in respect of this application and the application is dismissed."
23/0006+0367 2024-01-08
Dismissed

The tribunal found that the property factor had not breached the Code of Conduct and dismissed the homeowner's application.

Communication Financial Debt Recovery Complaints Handling
"Accordingly, the tribunal has determined that there are no breaches of the current Code of Conduct, and the tribunal will make no further order in respect of this application."
22/4041 2023-11-06
Dismissed

The homeowner alleged the property factor failed to comply with the code of conduct regarding the cleaning products used, but the Tribunal determined no breach had occurred and dismissed the application.

Communication Maintenance Other
"The Tribunal determines that the Property Factor has not failed to comply with OSP 1, 5 and section 2.5 of the 2021 Code."
23/1246 2023-11-06
Dismissed

The homeowner alleged the property factor failed to comply with OSP 6 regarding cleaning the bin store. The Tribunal found no breach of the code of conduct and dismissed the application.

Maintenance Communication
"The Tribunal determines that the Property Factor has not failed to comply with OSP 6 of the 2021 Code."
22/4172 2023-05-25
Rejected

The Tribunal rejected the homeowner's application because the homeowner did not provide the required documents and information, as per the rules.

"The Homeowner has failed to provide the information and documents required by Rule 43 of the Rules and Section 17 of the 2011 Act."
22/1586 2023-05-17
Rejected

The Tribunal rejected the Homeowner's application because she failed to provide the necessary information and documentation, as required by the rules and the 2011 Act.

"The basis of the decision is that the Applicant has failed to comply with Rule 5 and Rule 43 and Section 17 of the 2011 Act."
22/4180 2023-05-03
Rejected

The Tribunal rejected the homeowner's application because the homeowner failed to provide the necessary information and documents, as required by the rules and the Act.

"The Legal Member therefore determines that the application cannot be accepted. The application is rejected on that basis."
21/3219 2023-03-08
PFEO Complied PFEO Issued £750

The tribunal found the property factor failed to comply with the Code of Conduct and made a PFEO, ordering them to pay the homeowner £750 in compensation. The factor then complied with the order by crediting the sum to the homeowner's account.

Communication Maintenance Consultation Complaints Handling Other
"The tribunal determined that, in respect of the breaches of the Codes and the failure to comply with property factor’s duties, it should make a property factor enforcement order requiring the Property Factor to pay the sum of £750 of compensation to the Homeowner."
22/1769 2022-11-23
Dismissed

The Homeowner made an application complaining of breaches of the Code of Conduct. The Tribunal considered the evidence and found that the Property Factor had not breached the Code of Conduct and dismissed the application.

Communication Financial Maintenance Other
"The Tribunal determined that the Property Factor: - (i) has not failed to comply with the Section 14 duty in terms of the Act in respect of compliance with the Property Factor Code of Conduct 2012 (“the 2012 Code”) at Section 2.1, Section 3 and Section 6.1"
22/1654/1655 2022-05-31
PFEO Complied PFEO Issued £500

The Tribunal found Newton Property Management Limited in breach of Section 2.7 of the 2021 Code of Conduct and proposed to make a Property Factor Enforcement Order, requiring them to pay the homeowner compensation.

Communication Maintenance Financial Complaints Handling
"The Tribunal proposes to make the following Property Factor Enforcement Order (“PFEO”):“Within one month of the communication to the property factors of the PFEO, the property factors shall pay to the homeowner the sum of £500 by way of compensation for inconvenience and distress.”"
FTS/HPC/LM/21/2188 2022-02-17
PFEO Complied £862

The tribunal found that the factor breached the code, but a formal PFEO was not needed as the factor complied with the proposed PFEO terms by paying the homeowner the appropriate compensation.

Communication Consultation
"The Tribunal determined that the Property Factor having carried out the actions required by the Tribunal’s proposed Property Factor Enforcement Order (“PFEO”), there was no need to make the PFEO."
21/1283 2022-02-17
PFEO Complied £637

The Tribunal found the factor had breached the Code of Conduct and proposed a PFEO. The factor complied with the proposed order before the PFEO was formally issued, so the Tribunal did not make a PFEO.

Communication Consultation
"The Tribunal determined that the Property Factor having carried out the actions required by the Tribunal’s proposed Property Factor Enforcement Order (“PFEO”), there was no need to make the PFEO."
21/1412 2021-09-06
PFEO Complied £100

The tribunal found the factor breached the code of conduct and failed to carry out their duties, and proposed a PFEO. The tribunal ordered the factor to pay the applicant £642.95 and £100 for distress and inconvenience.

Communication Financial Consultation Complaints Handling
"The tribunal therefore intend to make the following property factor enforcement order (PFEO)"
21/1436 2021-08-30
Rejected

The Tribunal rejected the application due to the applicant's failure to provide necessary information, specifically evidence of notification to the factor, exhaustion of the factor's complaints procedure, and a letter of authority for the representative.

"The Tribunal rejects the application by the applicant dated 14th June 2021, being an application under section 17(1) of the Property Factors (Scotland) Act 2011."
21/0429 2021-08-05
Rejected

The Tribunal rejected the homeowner's application because they failed to provide necessary documentation as per the rules and the 2011 Act.

"The Legal Member therefore determines that the application cannot be accepted. The application is rejected on that basis."

How We Calculate Ratings

Ratings are based on a factor's adjusted adverse case rate per 10,000 properties for cases decided since 2021. Cases involving Property Factor Enforcement Orders (PFEOs) are weighted more heavily.

Rating Bands

CLEAN No cases decided against the factor since 2021
GREEN PFEO-weighted adverse rate at or below 10 per 10,000 properties (or 2 or fewer adverse cases with no PFEO breach)
ORANGE Weighted rate above 10 and up to 30 per 10,000
RED PFEO-weighted adverse rate above 30 per 10,000 properties
LIMITED Fewer than 50 properties on record to rate reliably

Special Rules

  • Factors with only 2 or fewer adverse cases (no PFEO breaches) are capped at GREEN
  • Pending or proposed PFEOs count at ×1.0 until the outcome is decided — there is no minimum-band override

Read our full methodology →

Data Updates

  • Last updated: October 2026
  • Next update: Monthly

We update quarterly. For the latest decisions, search the HPC directly →

Looking for alternatives?

We'll shortlist vetted factors with better tribunal records covering your area — free, no obligation.

Find a Better Factor

← Back to Newton Property Management Ltd profile